Compare taxes and see how much you save moving from New York to Canada
The New York to Toronto migration is one of the most discussed moves for finance, media, and tech workers in North America. New York state income tax at $100,000 is approximately $5,398, while Canada (federal + Ontario provincial) charges $24,385 — nearly five times more on a state-vs-country basis. However, New York residents also pay US federal tax (~$17,344 at $100K), bringing total NY burden to ~$22,742 — still slightly less than Canada's $24,385. NYC also charges an additional city income tax (3.078-3.876%) on top of state, making full NYC vs Toronto comparison closer than it appears. Americans moving from New York to Canada face a continuing US federal tax obligation — this worldwide income requirement does not end on relocation. The US-Canada tax treaty provides foreign tax credits that prevent double taxation, but annual US filing continues. Canada's universal healthcare is a significant counterbalance to higher income tax rates.
High Income Tax State
8 tax brackets from 4% to 10.9%
Federal + Provincial Tax
Federal 15-33% plus provincial tax (Ontario ~5.05-13.16%)
At $100,000 income:
New York state income tax ($5,398) is lower than Canada's combined tax ($24,385) at $100,000. Total NY (state + federal) of ~$22,742 is close to Canada. NYC city tax adds another 3-4% on top. US expats in Canada use foreign tax credits to avoid double taxation.
| Income | NY Tax | CA Tax | Savings | 10-Year |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $50,000 | $2,246 | $10,025 | -$7,779 Canada costs more | -$77,790 |
| $75,000 | $3,609 | $16,972 | -$13,363 Canada costs more | -$133,630 |
| $100,000 | $5,398 | $24,385 | -$18,987 Canada costs more | -$189,870 |
| $150,000 | $8,932 | $42,096 | -$33,164 Canada costs more | -$331,640 |
| $250,000 | $16,156 | $84,527 | -$68,371 Canada costs more | -$683,710 |
CountryTaxCalc.com is reader-supported. When you use our partner links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. This helps us provide free tax calculators and comparison tools. Learn more about our affiliate partnerships
★ 4.8 Trustpilot · 1,625 reviews
Americans abroad must still file a US tax return every year — no matter which country you move to. Greenback's CPAs specialise exclusively in US expat returns: FEIE, foreign tax credits, FBAR, and state filing requirements. Fixed pricing, no surprises.
⚠ Not the cheapest option — best for complex situations and expats who want a dedicated CPA.
Get Your US Expat Taxes Filed →★ 4.8 Trustpilot · 2,681 reviews
25 years filing US expat taxes across 190+ countries. Two-CPA review process. 50,000+ clients. 4.8 stars / 2,681 Trustpilot reviews.
⚠ Best for existing expats. If you're still in the US, a local CPA may be more cost-effective.
File With TFX — Expert Expat CPAs →★ 4.3 Trustpilot · 287,413 reviews
Moving money between your US accounts and your new country? Wise offers mid-market exchange rates with low transparent fees — typically 4-8x cheaper than banks for international transfers.
⚠ For currency exchange only — not a bank account replacement.
Transfer Money Internationally →Yes. All US citizens and green card holders must file a US federal tax return regardless of where they live. New York state tax ends once you successfully establish non-residency from New York (which is notoriously difficult — New York aggressively audits high-income departing residents). Your US federal obligation continues indefinitely. The US-Canada tax treaty allows you to claim foreign tax credits on Canadian taxes paid, preventing most double taxation.
Yes. New York State is one of the most aggressive states for pursuing former residents. You must establish domicile in Canada, spend fewer than 183 days in New York, and not maintain a permanent place of abode in the state. High-income New Yorkers are frequently audited for 'statutory residency' — if you maintain an apartment in New York and spend more than 183 days there, New York will tax you regardless of where your domicile is claimed to be.
A New York City resident pays state tax (up to 10.9%) + NYC city tax (up to 3.876%) + federal (up to 37%). At $100,000: ~$5,398 NY state + ~$3,100 NYC + ~$17,344 federal = ~$25,842 total. Canada (Ontario) at $100,000: ~$24,385. Surprisingly, total NYC burden is slightly higher than Toronto at $100K. At $150K+, the comparison remains close.
Wall Street (New York) typically offers higher USD base salaries than Bay Street (Toronto), particularly for investment banking, private equity, and hedge funds. However, Toronto's financial sector has grown significantly. After-tax income comparisons depend heavily on whether you work in midtown Manhattan (NYC city + state + federal) versus downtown Toronto (federal + Ontario). The gap in absolute after-tax income is smaller than the headline tax rates suggest.
Yes. Ontario's OHIP (Ontario Health Insurance Plan) provides universal healthcare funded through taxation. New York residents typically pay $400-$800/month in health insurance premiums (or have employer coverage). This healthcare value offsets some of Canada's higher income tax burden when comparing total cost of living.
Americans with Canadian bank accounts must file FBAR (FinCEN Form 114) if aggregate foreign account values exceed $10,000 at any point during the year. FATCA Form 8938 is required for higher thresholds ($50,000-$200,000+ depending on filing status and residency). Canadian RRSPs and TFSAs have specific US reporting requirements. Greenback Expat Tax Services specialises in these filings for US expats in Canada.
The US federal long-term capital gains rate is 0%, 15%, or 20% depending on income. New York adds state tax on capital gains at ordinary income rates (up to 10.9%) plus NYC tax. Canada includes 50% of capital gains in taxable income (effective rate roughly half the marginal income tax rate). For high earners, US total capital gains treatment (federal + New York) is generally more favorable than Canada's at equivalent income levels.